New releases every Wednesday. Back issues from every era. A community that celebrates the stories, artists, and collectors who make this hobby extraordinary.
All Star Comics and Collectibles was born from a simple belief: that the best stories deserve the best community. Located right on Montauk Highway in the heart of Lindenhurst, we've built a space where first-time buyers and veteran collectors alike feel right at home.
Whether you're hunting for that elusive first appearance, catching up on the latest superhero sagas, or browsing through decades of graphic novels, our shelves are stocked with care and our doors are always open. Come say hello — we save your pull list like it's our own.
From the silver age to the modern era, from Marvel and DC to the indies — our shelves hold something for everyone.
The latest issues from Marvel, DC, Image, Dark Horse, and the top indie publishers — every Wednesday.
Complete story arcs and standalone masterpieces. Perfect for readers who like their stories bound and ready.
Dig through decades of issues. From key issues to deep cuts, we've got the gold and silver age you're searching for.
Action figures, statues, and premium collectibles from the biggest franchises in pop culture.
Pokemon, Magic: The Gathering, One Piece, and more. Sealed product, singles, and booster boxes.
The newest manga volumes and anime merchandise, from shonen hits to literary masterpieces.
Set aside your weekly issues and we'll hold them until you come in. Never miss a release again.
Can't find it? We'll order it for you from our wholesale distributors. Even the hard-to-find issues.
Have vintage issues or collectibles gathering dust? We buy quality inventory and offer fair prices.
Signings, meetups, and release day events. Stop by and connect with fellow fans in person.
New release day is Wednesday — get there early!
Swing by the shop, give us a call, or drop an email. We'd love to hear from you.
